Best Creator Platform 2025: A Comparison of Postion vs. Substack vs. Ghost vs. Medium

Choosing a creator platform is one of the biggest decisions you'll make. It's not just software; it's the foundation of your digital home and your business. Get it right, and you build a sustainable business. Get it wrong, and you face frustrating limitations and unfair fees.

This is the creator's "Great Migration." You might be looking for a Substack alternative or moving from a blogging platform that no longer serves you. The options—Substack, Medium, Ghost, and new contenders like Postion—all promise to be the best. But they are fundamentally different.

This guide is the ultimate creator platform comparison to help you make the right choice.

Before diving in, it's helpful to have a clear framework. We've compiled a list of 10 questions every creator should ask before choosing a platform to guide your thinking.

Once you have your priorities straight, you can evaluate the platforms on the four pillars that truly matter.

Pillar 1: Monetization & Fees (Who Really Gets Paid?)

Your platform should help you capture your content's value, not take an excessive cut.

• Substack: The model is famously simple: free to start, but they take a 10% cut of your revenue, on top of Stripe's fees. This is punishing as you grow, costing you thousands every year. As we break down in detail, Substack's 10% fee is costing you far more than you think.
• Medium: Monetization is indirect through the Partner Program. You have no control over pricing or the customer relationship. It's like writing for a magazine, not running a business.
• Ghost: You keep 100% of your revenue (minus Stripe fees). The trade-off is a fixed monthly hosting fee. For a detailed Substack vs Ghost analysis, it's worth seeing a full cost breakdown.
• Postion: We believe in fair pricing. With a small, flat transaction fee, you keep the vast majority of your earnings. This frees you to focus on building diversified income streams all in one place.

The Verdict: For serious creators, a model that doesn't punish growth is critical.

Pillar 2: Content Ownership & Control (Are You a Renter or an Owner?)

This is the most overlooked—and most important—factor when considering how to choose a creator platform.

• Medium: You are a renter. Your content lives on Medium.com, under their brand. Many creators seek a Medium alternative for this very reason.
• Substack: It's a step up, but your site lives on a yourname.substack.com domain by default, and you have almost zero control over design, functionality, or SEO.
• Ghost: The gold standard for ownership. You have full control. The downside? This control comes with complexity, leading many to seek a Ghost alternative.
• Postion: We provide the ownership of Ghost with the simplicity of Substack. You get a custom domain from day one, which is essential for long-term SEO success. We believe data ownership for creators is your most valuable asset.

The Verdict: True ownership means having your own domain, brand, and data, without needing a computer science degree.

Pillar 3: Growth & SEO (Is the Platform Helping You Grow?)

A creator platform shouldn't just host your content; it should help new people discover it.

• Medium: Benefits from a high domain authority, but you're ultimately building their SEO authority, not your own.
• Substack: Notoriously weak for SEO, making it a poor choice for long-term organic growth.
• Ghost: Very powerful for SEO, but you are responsible for implementing the strategy.
• Postion: Built for growth. We provide a lightning-fast, SEO-optimized foundation and tools like our AI Search and Knowledge Hub to help you maximize your content's value.

The Verdict: The best creator platform is an active partner in your growth.

Pillar 4: Ease of Use & Creator Experience

Power means nothing if the platform is a chore to use.

• Substack & Medium: Both are incredibly simple.
• Ghost: The most powerful, but also the most complex. It's often overkill for non-technical creators.
• Postion: Our core philosophy: powerful, not complicated. We offer a beautiful writing experience with integrated tools like an AI assistant and content repurposing features, letting you maximize your reach without the burnout.

The At-a-Glance Comparison: Substack vs Ghost vs Medium vs Postion

Stop Renting, Start Owning

The "Great Migration" is about moving to a creator platform that empowers you.

While Substack and Medium are great for starting, and Ghost is excellent for tinkerers, Postion is built for the serious, independent creator who values ownership, growth, and fair monetization without the technical headaches.

It's your content. It's your audience. It's your business. It's time you had a platform that treats it that way.

Ready to build your digital home? See how Postion empowers independent creators.